Searchlight Logo
special_image

    • News
      • Front Page
      • News
      • Breaking News
      • Press Release
      • Features
      • Special Features
      • From the Courts
      • Sports
      • Regional / World
    • Opinions
      • Editorial
      • Our Readers’ Opinions
      • Bassy – Love Vine
      • Dr. Fraser- Point of View
      • R. Rose – Eye of the Needle
      • On Target
      • Dr Jozelle Miller
      • The World Around Us
      • Random Thoughts
    • Advice
      • Kitchen Corner
      • What’s on Fleek this week
      • Health Wise
      • Physician’s Weekly
      • Business Buzz
      • Hey Rosie!
      • Prime the pump
    • ePaper
    • Obituaries
      • In Memoriam / Acknowledgement
      • Tribute
    • Contact Us
      • Advertise With Us
      • Letters To The Editor
      • General Contact Information
      • Contact our Webmaster
    • About Us
      • Privacy Policy
      • Interactive Media Ltd
      • St. Vincent & the Grenadines
    • Subscribe
    • News
      • Front Page
      • News
      • Breaking News
      • Press Release
      • Features
      • Special Features
      • From the Courts
      • Sports
      • Regional / World
    • Opinions
      • Editorial
      • Our Readers’ Opinions
      • Bassy – Love Vine
      • Dr. Fraser- Point of View
      • R. Rose – Eye of the Needle
      • On Target
      • Dr Jozelle Miller
      • The World Around Us
      • Random Thoughts
    • Advice
      • Kitchen Corner
      • What’s on Fleek this week
      • Health Wise
      • Physician’s Weekly
      • Business Buzz
      • Hey Rosie!
      • Prime the pump
    • ePaper
    • Obituaries
      • In Memoriam / Acknowledgement
      • Tribute
    • Contact Us
      • Advertise With Us
      • Letters To The Editor
      • General Contact Information
      • Contact our Webmaster
    • About Us
      • Privacy Policy
      • Interactive Media Ltd
      • St. Vincent & the Grenadines
    • Subscribe
Understanding the Law
August 17, 2012

Randolph Toussaint v the Attorney

Two weeks ago, the recent Privy Council judgment in the case of Toussaint v the Attorney General was examined and, as promised, we shall continue with the same.

The appellant, Randolph Toussaint, who challenged the exppropriation of his property, sought to have statements used by the Prime Minister in the budget debates in the House of Assembly on December 5, 2007 to support his claim that the reason for the action of the Government was political{{more}}. The trial judge held that the statement could not be used. The Court of Appeal agreed that it could not be used, as the permission of the Speaker of the House of Assembly had not been obtained.

Their Lordships felt that the Prime Minister in explaining the acquisition of the property in the House focused exclusively on Mr Toussaint’s acquisition of the land in the 1990’s and his relationship with the previous government. Even after he recited the declaration “He made no mention of any need or purpose to acquire the land for a Learning Resource Centre.” They thought that the statement — “We have acted, whoever thinks, whatever individual may think that he possessed a right there is always the law courts. But we cannot sit idly by” – further supported his reason for the acquisition.

Their Lordships thought that the statement by the Prime Minister was “potentially relevant to Mr Toussaint’s claim as an admission or explanation of the executive’s motivation” for the appropriation and was “the best possible contemporaneous evidence.”

Their Lordships examined the implications of the Privileges Act of 1966, which, according to sections 3 and 16, buttress the Speaker’s immunity from the jurisdiction of the Court. In pursuant of these sections, statements made in the House of Assembly could not be used in evidence in the law court. However, this law must succumb to the constitutional rights of a person. Everyone has not only the constitutional right to own land but the right of access to the court to enforce that right. Further a person has a right to non-discriminatory treatment under the law. The constitution is the ultimate law of the land and any existing law must be subjected to “modifications adaptations or qualifications as necessary to avoid any inconsistency” with it. As an existing law the Privilege Act must give way to the Constitution.

According to the constitution, property should not be taken away compulsorily, except for a public purpose. Anyone whose property is taken away compulsorily must have adequate compensation. The constitution also provides for access to the court to determine whether or not the acquisition was properly carried out. Their Lordships found that if Mr Toussaint was not able to rely upon the Prime Minister’s statement in the budget debates to explain the action of the executive, his constitutional right would be unduly and effectively undermined.

To the submission that parliamentary privilege has been accepted as legitimate by the European Court of Human Rights, their Lordships observed that nothing in its judgments suggest that the absolute discretion of the Speaker of the House would pervade over a fundamental right.

Costs

The issue of costs was also raised in both courts below. The High Court had struck out the matter in favour of the Attorney General as costs in the cause; the Court of Appeal had set aside the Judge’s order and directed no costs in both courts. Their Lordships directed costs in favour of Mr Toussaint in all three courts.

Ada Johnson is a solicitor and barrister-at-law.
E-mail address is: exploringthelaw@yahoo.com

  • FacebookComments
  • ALSO IN THE NEWS
    Barrouallie woman, charged in stabbing death of boyfriend
    Front Page
    Barrouallie woman, charged in stabbing death of boyfriend
    Webmaster 
    October 10, 2025
    A Barrouallie woman, allegedly killed her boyfriend who was stabbed in the neck with a knife, has been granted bail in the sum of $30,000. Brittany Au...
    Independence celebrations 2025 slated to be spectuclar
    Front Page
    Independence celebrations 2025 slated to be spectuclar
    Webmaster 
    October 10, 2025
    Chairman of the National Independence Committee, Rodney Small, is urging people across St Vincent and the Grenadines (SVG), to attend the various acti...
    Second event sees mentally challenged inmates involved in football
    Front Page
    Second event sees mentally challenged inmates involved in football
    Webmaster 
    October 10, 2025
    A second event, geared at helping inmates at His Majesty’s Prison (HMP) with varying mental health issues better cope with some of their problems, was...
    Teenager aims to become Prime Minister
    Front Page
    Teenager aims to become Prime Minister
    Webmaster 
    October 10, 2025
    by Grace Francis At just 19 years old, Arron Dennie has set his sights high, aspiring not only to become a lawyer but ultimately, to serve as Prime Mi...
    New Police Officers pledge to serve with courage, discipline and integrity
    Front Page
    New Police Officers pledge to serve with courage, discipline and integrity
    Webmaster 
    October 10, 2025
    A total of 113 police recruits gathered at the Arnos Vale Playing field last Friday, October, 3,2025, for the Passing Out Parade. The 42nd cohort of r...
    Ministry of Agriculture launches World Food Day Programme
    Front Page
    Ministry of Agriculture launches World Food Day Programme
    Webmaster 
    October 10, 2025
    The Ministry of Agriculture on Thursday, October, 9, 2025, launched a programme of activities leading up to World Food Day that is observed globally o...
    News
    Smart tells Cabinet he does not want work with the MOA
    News
    Smart tells Cabinet he does not want work with the MOA
    Webmaster 
    October 10, 2025
    Gabriel ‘Webb’ Smart informed the Cabinet on Wednesday, October, 1 2025, that he does not want a full time job with the Ministry of Agriculture. He re...
    Criminals not welcomed, will be tracked – PM Mottley
    News
    Criminals not welcomed, will be tracked – PM Mottley
    Webmaster 
    October 10, 2025
    Criminals attempting to move between the four Caribbean Community (Caricom) countries that from this month began allowing the unrestricted movement of...
    DTVE records highest enrolment
    News
    DTVE records highest enrolment
    Webmaster 
    October 10, 2025
    For the first time, the Division of Technical and Vocational Education (DTVE) of the St Vincent and the Grenadines Community College (SVGC), has recor...
    Man who smashed his sister’s washing machine to pay compensation
    From the Courts, News
    Man who smashed his sister’s washing machine to pay compensation
    Webmaster 
    October 10, 2025
    A Largo Height man was ordered to compensate his sister $2,500 after he smashed her washing machine because the noise bothered him. Kenton Harris appe...
    Young farmers receive training in Smart Agricultural Practices
    News
    Young farmers receive training in Smart Agricultural Practices
    Webmaster 
    October 10, 2025
    Seventy-five young Vincentian farmers are receiving training courses in smart agricultural techniques through the Embassy of the Republic of China on ...

    E-EDITION
    ePaper
    google_play
    app_store
    Subscribe Now
    • Interactive Media Ltd. • P.O. Box 152 • Kingstown • St. Vincent and the Grenadines • Phone: 784-456-1558 © Copyright Interactive Media Ltd.. All rights reserved.
    We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it.Ok